If you haven’t gotten to read our report, “A Safe Place to Stay: Combating
Homelessness, Police Violence and Jim Crow in Greensboro”, please take a
There you will find the full length report, along with a powerpoint
presentation and other tools to use for advocacy.
Also, below is a good article about the report printed in Yes! Weekly.
House Keys Not Handcuffs!
-The Homeless Union of Greensboro
More than shelters needed for Greensboro homeless to have ‘safe place to
Ian McDowell <yesweekly.com/author/ian-mcdowell/>
November 26, 2019
Editor’s picks <yesweekly.com/category/edspicks/>, News
Views : 94
[image: More than shelters needed for Greensboro homeless to have ‘safe
place to stay’]
On Thursday, millions of Americans will gorge themselves in ritualized
thankfulness, then sleep it off in warm bedrooms they own or rent. Earlier
this month, three local academics issued the findings from surveys of over
200 Greensboro residents who lack even bedrooms to be thankful for.
*A Safe Place to Stay: Combating Homelessness, Police Violence and Jim Crow
an 85-page report by Guilford College professors Krista Craven, Ph.D., and
Sonalini Sapra, Ph.D., and University of North Carolina at Greensboro
professor Justin Harmon, Ph.D., researched and presented in collaboration
with the Homeless Union of Greensboro <www.homelessunion.org/>. The
document argues that affordable permanent housing, rather than shelter beds
or other temporary “band-aid” solutions, is what Greensboro’s homeless need
most. It also alleges that the city’s homeless are regularly abused by the
Greensboro Police Department.
The third and longest of the report’s seven sections, “The Criminalization
of Homelessness and Legal Representation,” begins by calling the homeless
“more likely to be harassed, cited or arrested by the police departments
that enforce ordinances targeting those in poverty (e.g., laws the prohibit
vagrancy, panhandling, loitering, sleeping in public).” The section ends
with five pages on the police homicide
Marcus Deon Smith, the homeless African-American man fatally hogtied by GPD
officers during the 2018 North Carolina Folk Festival.
Co-author Harmon, an assistant professor of Community and Therapeutic
Recreation in the UNCG School of Health and Human Sciences, wrote in an
email that the report was conceived several months before Smith’s death,
but includes it “both out of respect for his life and the need to keep the
case in the public eye.” Smith’s death, Harmon stated, “highlights several
major problems in Greensboro, including stigma/profiling, the need for
mental health resources and training, and government’s unparalleled power
in controlling narratives.”
Harmon made those statements in email correspondence with YES! Weekly and
Sapra, engaged teaching specialist in the Guilford College Political
Science Department. Harmon and Sapra’s co-author Craven, an assistant
professor of Justice and Police Studies at Guilford College, is on parental
leave through February and was unavailable for an interview.
“I think the Marcus Deon Smith case exemplifies what we are trying to
demonstrate in our report around the systematic criminalization of people
experiencing homelessness in Greensboro,” Sapra wrote in an email. “His
death was completely avoidable had the city taken more effective steps to
stop harassing and criminalizing people living on the street.”
Section 3.1 of the report, “Interactions Between Homeless Persons and Law
Enforcement Officers in Greensboro,” names 10 GPD officers as having the
highest percentage of arrests or citations of homeless African-Americans on
“nuisance” offenses. The study’s methodology determined as homeless those
whose arrest or citation report listed their permanent address as the
Interactive Resource Center (IRC) or Greensboro Urban Ministries (GUM). The
officers allegedly targeting black homeless men in the report are Samuel A.
Alvarez, William D. Coble, Christopher A. Ferguson, Detraveus K. Forte,
Thomas A. Henderson, Matthew L. Hukill, Michael C. Miller, Wayne S.
Morrison, Willson J. Moss and Brent R. Sepulveda.
Using the results of public information requests, the report tallied
arrests made and citations issued by those 10 officers for violating city
statues and ordinances against the following: Standing, Sitting or Lying
Upon Highways or Streets; Failure to Leave Premises; Second Degree
Trespass; Blocking or impeding streets or sidewalk access; Urinating or
defecating in public; Solicitation and Distribution of items in public
parking garages and public parking lots; Harassing in Public Places; and
Begging or Soliciting Alms.
According to figure 3.4 on page 24, Percentage of Total of
Arrests/Citations by Officer of Individuals who are Black and also listed
IRC/GUM as their Address, between January 2017 and May 2019, 100% of all
individuals arrested or cited by officers Miller and Forte on these eight
counts are black and homeless, as are 94.4% of those arrested or cited by
Henderson and 85.2% of those cited or arrested by Alvarez on the same
counts during the same timeframe.
“That black/homeless males appear to have been singled out for harassment,
citation, and arrest is concerning,” wrote Harmon in an email, but he
emphasized that the report’s ultimate objective is more than just
“This is nothing more than a resource to help the city move forward in
making sweeping changes to help the community get better.”
To that end, the report concludes with “Policy Proposals by the Homeless
Union of Greensboro,” quoted verbatim below:
1. We have a right to self-determination: We demand a seat at the table and
a say in policies that affect our lives. We call on local government to
develop a plan to combat homelessness that is accountable to the needs and
priorities of people experiencing homelessness by including them in
decision-making processes from the start.
2. Everybody’s got a right to live: We demand an immediate end to police
harassment, brutality, and the killing of people. In particular, we call
for an immediate end to targeting and violence towards black people, other
people of color, LGBTQIA people, people living with disabilities, people
experiencing homelessness, and other marginalized people. We demand
accountability and citizen oversight for police and public employees who
violate the rights of citizens.
3. Housing is a human right: We demand safe, decent, and affordable housing
fit for human beings, not underfunded Band-Aid services.
4. We have a right to living wages and adequate compensation: We demand
living wage employment and real opportunities to escape poverty and
5. We have a right to due process: We demand fair treatment before the
court for low-income people. This means adequate legal representation in
both criminal and civil courts – including evictions – and an end to the
money bail system.
6. Healthcare is a human right: We demand adequate access to healthcare and
services such as emergency shelters, hygiene facilities, and places that
serve food. We demand that all service providers respect our rights,
involve clients in decision-making, and have a fair grievance process for
7. We have a right to be treated with dignity: We demand access to
non-police emergency services. Non-police personnel are best equipped to
deal with and de-escalate crisis related to mental health, drug-use, and
8. Everyone has a right to a safe place to stay. Homelessness is not a
crime: We demand safe and legal places for people experiencing homelessness
to sleep without the fear of police harassment and violence.
9. We have a right to be secure in our persons and free from unreasonable
searches and seizures: We demand local government adopt policies to protect
the rights of people experiencing homelessness.
10. We have a right to equal treatment and opportunity: All people
addressing issues related to homelessness ought to commit to anti-racism
and anti-oppression work and view it as central to that work.
Homeless man sleeping on the sidewalk in Atlanta
Photos courtesy of Wikimedia Commons
In an email, Sapra described the report as originating in an April 2018
conversation between Harmon and Marcus Hyde of the Homeless Union of
“They talked about the possibility of doing more systematic research on
homelessness in Greensboro. Justin reached out to me and asked if I was
interested. He convened a meeting in the early summer of 2018 with faculty
from both Guilford College and UNC Greensboro. In the end, students from
Guilford and UNCG collected the data, and the report was compiled by
Krista, Justin, myself, with input from the Homeless Union of Greensboro.”
Harmon described Sapra and Craven as using a methodology called
Participatory Action Research (PAR).
“That methodology is very time-consuming, but its purpose (and value) is to
draw from the expertise and preferences of those whom are the object of
investigation (i.e., those experiencing homelessness).”
“We touched base with the Homeless Union and the Greensboro Urban Ministry
at several points during the research process and also engaged in
collaborative data analysis with the Homeless Union,” Sapra elaborated.
Hyde described the process further.
“We wanted to do an in-depth survey of folks on the streets to learn more
about their priorities, so we began doing surveys on our own as a group.
Then, I brought up the idea of doing it with academics, and the group got
excited. Sonalini, Krista and Justin were the three who were willing and
able to put the hard work into doing a community-driven survey.”
Hyde also explained why the report devotes so much space to police
“The number of times the same officers were named by participants is
shocking. They are known problems that the police department has covered
for over a long period of time, Samuel Alvarez being one. He was involved
in the Jose Charles case, the Zared Jones case, and other cases of police
misconduct and people on the streets have named him many times as an
especially cruel officer who goes beyond his legal authority to harass and
harm black people and people experiencing homelessness.”
Hyde said that while he appreciated the coverage other media outlets have
given to the issue of alleged police harassment, he’s been disappointed by
the lack of attention to the report’s final recommendations.
“We offered a litany of policies that would both reduce homelessness in
Greensboro and improve conditions for people experiencing it. Housing is
the only long-term solution to homelessness, and it’s also – as the report
indicates – cheaper than keeping people in a cycle of shelters, emergency
rooms and jail.”
Hyde also repeated a point brought up by Beth Mckee-Huger, retired
executive director of the Greensboro Housing Coalition, at the Nov. 12
presentation of the report at McGirt-Horton Library.
“Voters in Greensboro passed a $25 million affordable housing bond in 2016,
but they haven’t prioritized low-income housing, which is needed the most.
Instead, they dump a lot of money into middle-income housing, which may be
$800-$900 per month, and because they leverage a lot of private capital in
the process, the city likes to celebrate those developments, even when they
are placed in low-income neighborhoods where the pre-existing housing is
cheaper than the new ‘affordable’ housing is being built. Low-income
housing is what’s needed most, but the city isn’t prioritizing it.”
In a text last Thursday, Michelle Kennedy, executive director of the
Interactive Resource Center and At-large Representative to the Greensboro
City Council, appeared to agree with at least some of the report’s findings.
“Yes, we lack affordable housing options,” Kennedy wrote. “The City is
moving forward with partners for a large scale Permanent Supportive Housing
She appeared to agree with the report’s findings on the burden imposed on
Greensboro’s homeless population by court costs and the cash bail system,
stating those expenses “are especially hard on folks we [the IRC] serve.”
Kennedy also stated that Greensboro lacks adequate shelter beds. “Our
shelter system is a high barrier, which creates difficulties for those with
the highest acuity.”
Of the arrest and citation figures, Kenney texted that “our homeless
community is disproportionately black and male, so any data around homeless
[and] police interactions will show disproportionality.”
Ian McDowell is the author of two published novels, numerous anthologized
short stories, and a whole lot of nonfiction and journalism, some of which
he’s proud of and none of which he’s ashamed of.
Tags : A Safe Place to Stay
<yesweekly.com/tag/a-safe-place-to-stay/>, A Safe Place to Stay:
African-American <yesweekly.com/tag/african-american/>, begging
<yesweekly.com/tag/begging/>, Beth Mckee-Huger
<yesweekly.com/tag/black/>, black men
<yesweekly.com/tag/black-men/>, Brent R. Sepulveda
<yesweekly.com/tag/brent-r-sepulveda/>, Christopher A. Ferguson
<yesweekly.com/tag/christopher-a-ferguson/>, Community and
of Homelessness <yesweekly.com/tag/criminalization-of-homelessness/>
, Detraveus K. Forte <yesweekly.com/tag/detraveus-k-forte/>, GPD
<yesweekly.com/tag/gpd/>, Greensboro Housing Coalition
<yesweekly.com/tag/greensboro-housing-coalition/>, Greensboro Police
<yesweekly.com/tag/greensboro-police/>, Greensboro Police Department
College <yesweekly.com/tag/guilford-college/>, GUM
<yesweekly.com/tag/homelessness/>, Interactive Resource Center
<yesweekly.com/tag/irc/>, Justice and Police Studies
<yesweekly.com/tag/justice-and-police-studies/>, Justin Harmon
<yesweekly.com/tag/justin-harmon/>, Krista Craven
<yesweekly.com/tag/krista-craven/>, Law Enforcement Officers
<yesweekly.com/tag/male/>, Marcus Deon Smith
<yesweekly.com/tag/marcus-deon-smith/>, Matthew L. Hukill
<yesweekly.com/tag/matthew-l-hukill/>, McGirt-Horton Library
<yesweekly.com/tag/men/>, Michael C. Miller
<yesweekly.com/tag/michael-c-miller/>, Michelle Kennedy
<yesweekly.com/tag/police/>, Police Violence and Jim Crow in
A. Alvarez <yesweekly.com/tag/samuel-a-alvarez/>, Sonalini Sapra
<yesweekly.com/tag/thanksgiving/>, Thomas A. Henderson
<yesweekly.com/tag/uncg/>, UNCG School of Health and Human Sciences
of North Carolina at Greensboro
S. Morrison <yesweekly.com/tag/wayne-s-morrison/>, William D. Coble
<yesweekly.com/tag/william-d-coble/>, Willson J. Moss
<yesweekly.com/tag/willson-j-moss/>, zared jones